//my.katapy.tv/courttv-en/video/courttvlibrary/111437/111440-season-1/190520-accused-uncles-defense-moves-to-toss-charges-in-5-year-olds-murder-case

Court TV

HomeCLIPSAccused Uncle's Defense Moves to Toss Charges in 5-Year-Old's Murder Case

Accused Uncle's Defense Moves to Toss Charges in 5-Year-Old's Murder Case

TV-14 | CLIPS | Season 1 | 2026

After the state rested its case in the murder and assault trial involving 5-year-old Paitin Fields, the defense moved to dismiss the charges, arguing prosecutors failed to present sufficient evidence identifying David Prevatte as the perpetrator. The state countered that circumstantial evidence, including testimony about Paitin's injuries and DNA profiles found on Prevatte, was enough for the jury to consider. The defense called the state's theory "purely conjecture," arguing the evidence left key questions about the alleged sexual assaults unanswered. Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today Join the Investigation Newsletter Court TV Podcast Join the Court TV Community to get access to perks: FOLLOW THE CASE: Facebook Twitter/X Instagram TikTok YouTube WATCH 140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE WHERE-TO-WATCH

Keywords:Courttv




  • Season 1

Lindsay Clancy Juror Intimidation Suspect Makes SHOCKING Claim

Dawn Light, the woman accused of intimidating a juror in the Lindsay Clancy trial, was surrounded by media as she left the Plymouth District Courthouse Wednesda...

Lindsay Clancy Juror Intimidation Suspect Appears in Court

Dawn Light, a 56-year-old woman, was in court Wednesday morning after being arrested Tuesday afternoon outside the Plymouth District Courthouse in Massachusetts...

Charlie Kirk Prosecutors Reveal What They Say Drove His Killer

Prosecutors delivered their rebuttal during Tyler Robinsons pretrial hearing, arguing that Robinsons disregard for human life was evident by his alleged decisio...

Lindsay Clancy Jury STILL Deadlocked on Day 5 of Deliberations

On Wednesday, after 27 hours of deliberations, the jury in the case of Lindsay Clancy was still deadlocked. They first told the judge they were deadlocked on Tu...

Tiger Woods Takes Plea Deal in DUI Case

Tiger Woods appeared in a Florida courtroom Wednesday and pleaded no contest as prosecutors reduced his original DUI charge to willful and wanton reckless drivi...

Lindsay Clancy Jurors Look 'Ready to Be Done'

Jurors in the case against Lindsay Clancy returned to the Plymouth District Courthouse Thursday after nearly 30 hours of deliberations. Law

Michigan Mom Sentenced for Abandoning Kids in Squalor

Michigan mom Kelli Bryant was sentenced on Tuesday after pleading guilty to three counts of child abuse. Bryant was accused of abandoning her kids to live in a ...

Lindsay Clancy's Lawyer Brings Her Letters Of Support

Before the Lindsay Clancy trial deliberations began on Thursday, Kevin Reddington spoke to the media. He stated that he was proud of what he had done in this tr...

One Holdout Juror STALLS Lindsay Clancy Verdict

After more than 35 hours of deliberation in the case against Lindsay Clancy, the jury was sent back for a third time after sending the judge a note. Clancys law...

Lindsay Clancy Trial: TENSE Sidebar Over Holdout Juror

The jurors in the Lindsay Clancy case have gone back to deliberate for a third time after one of the jurors reportedly won't budge on thier decision. The courtr...

Lindsay Clancy Lawyer Accuses Holdout Juror of 'Lying'

On Friday, the jury returned for a seventh day of deliberations in the case against Lindsay Clancy. Before the jurors entered the courtroom, the defense and jud...

Lindsay Clancy Judge Declares Mistrial Then Defense Fights Back!

After the Lindsay Clancy court received another note claiming the jurors could not come to a unanimous verdict, the judge said he had no choice but to declare a...

Lindsay Clancy Jury STILL Split 11-1 as Tensions Rise

The jury returned to deliberate in the case against Lindsay Clancy on Friday, reaching 36 hours of deliberations while remaining split 11-1. Law

Lindsay Clancy Lawyer: Mistrial 'Would Not Be Fair' to Her

Before court began Friday, Lindsay Clancys defense lawyer Kevin Reddington was once again surrounded by reporters and asked about the ongoing jury deadlock and ...

HUNG JURY in Lindsay Clancy Case — Mistrial Declared!

A judge issued a mistrial in the high-profile case against Massachusetts mom Lindsay Clancy after jurors could not agree on a unanimous verdict. Prosecutors and...

Lindsay Clancy Courtroom Fireworks ROCKS Verdict Opinions

The Lindsay Clancy trial came to a dramatic turning point Friday as Judge William Sullivan and defense attorney Kevin Reddington went head to head in a heated c...

Lindsay Clancy Retrial? DA Timothy Cruz Reveals Next Steps

Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz addressed reporters Friday after a mistrial was declared in the Lindsay Clancy case, but said he has not yet deci...

Lindsay Clancy Emergency Hearing: Defense Fights Mistrial

Lindsay Clancy and her defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, appeared before the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court for an emergency hearing after Judge William...

Lindsay Clancy Lawyer Addresses Patrick Clancy Speculation

While talking to the media after the judge declared a mistrial in Lindsay Clancys case, her lawyer, Kevin Reddington, addressed growing online speculation about...

Lindsay Clancy Supporters Release Butterflies After Mistrial

After a mistrial was declared in the Lindsay Clancy case, supporters gathered outside the Plymouth District Courthouse to release butterflies in her honor. Peop...

Lindsay Clancy Lawyer Says His Case 'Crushed' DA Timothy Cruz

Lindsay Clancys lawyer, Kevin Reddington, spoke outside the Plymouth District Courthouse after a mistrial was declared. He stated that Lindsay was a brave and a...

'TikTok Social Worker' Barred From Testifying in Clancy Trial

Emily Thorndike, who worked at McLean Hospital until 2021, took the stand as the judge considered whether she could testify for Lindsay Clancys defense. Clancys...

Lawyer Allegedly Pulls Loaded Gun on Wife | OH v. Matthew Exton | Full Openings

Ohio lawyer Matthew Exton is accused of attempting to kill his estranged wife and her parents at the grand opening of a restaurant on April 11, 2025. Prosecutor...

Chilling 911 Calls Reveal Lawyer's Alleged Attack on Wife

Jurors listened to the terrifying 911 calls from people reporting that lawyer Matthew Exton was allegedly attempting to shoot his wife and her parents at an Ohi...

Customer Spots Lawyer's Odd Behavior Before Restaurant Attack

A customer who visited an Ohio restaurant during a gun attack revealed the strange behavior of lawyer Matthew Exton. The customer stated that Exton was allegedl...

Plastic Surgeon Accused of Killing Lawyer Chooses Bench Trial

Dr. Tomasz Kosowski, who will represent himself in his upcoming murder trial, stated in court on Monday that he wants a bench trial. Kosowski emphasized that he...

Father Spoke of Missing Sons in Past Tense: FBI

John Skeltons preliminary hearing continued on Thursday. Kelly Liberti, who was a special agent with the FBIs Child Abduction Rapid Deployment team and conducte...

MI v. John Skelton | Hearing for Man Accused of Killing 3 Sons | Full Closings

Closing arguments were delivered in John Skeltons preliminary hearing on Thursday. Skelton is accused of killing his three young sons, Andrew, 9, Alexander, 7, ...

Woman Accused of Holding Stepson Captive for 20 Years Heads to Trial

Kimberly Sullivan attended a pretrial hearing Friday after rejecting plea offers and choosing to take her case to trial. Sullivan is accused of holding her step...

Father Accused of Killing 3 Sons Will Face Trial for Their 2010 Deaths

After closing arguments were delivered on Thursday in John Skeltons preliminary hearing, a Michigan judge ruled that Skelton will face trial for his sons disapp...

Texas Killing Fields Trial: Suspect's Sister Calls Him 'Ruthless'

Pamela Croft, James Elmore's sister, testified in his manslaughter trial over the 1984 death of 16-year-old Laura Miller. Croft described Elmore as a known liar...

Doctor Sentenced for Force-Feeding Abortion Pills to Girlfriend

Suspended Ohio doctor Hassan-James Abbas learned his fate on Friday after pleading no contest to force-feeding his pregnant girlfriend abortion pills in Decembe...

Texas Killing Fields: Father Turned Grief Into Search Mission

Tim Miller, the father of Laura Miller, spent more than 40 years searching for answers after his daughter disappeared in 1984. Miller founded Texas EquuSearch i...

'Holdout' Juror in Lindsay Clancy Case is Identified

New information has been reported about the "holdout" juror in the Lindsay Clancy case. After a juror recently spoke out in an exclusive interview, the juror co...

Judge Locks Up Mom for Toddler Son's Murder

Amanda Maison was sentenced to nine to fifteen years in prison after pleading guilty in connection to the tragic abuse and death of her 4-year-old son, Matthew....

'House of Horrors' Grandfather Deemed Not Competent for Trial

On Wednesday, Gary Siders Sr. was found not competent to stand trial following a court-ordered evaluation. Gary Siders Jr. and his wife, Elizabeth, face charges...

Texas Killing Fields Suspect Confessed Role in Teen's Murder: Prosecution

The State delivered closing arguments in James Elmore's manslaughter trial, arguing that Elmore confessed to having a role in Laura Miller's murder during conve...

Texas Killing Fields Suspects Told Teen They Killed Before: Testimony

Karey Dotson testified in the trial of James Elmore, who is charged with manslaughter in the 1984 death of 16-year-old Laura Miller. Dotson, who knew Miller, to...

James Elmore Only Provided Teen's Dad With Info for Money: Defense

James Elmore's defense delivered closing arguments in his manslaughter trial, arguing that he only provided Laura Miller's father with information about her dis...

Texas Killing Fields Trial | TX v. James Elmore | Full Closings

Closing arguments were delivered in James Elmore's trial, where he's charged with manslaughter in the 1984 death of 16-year-old Laura Miller, whose body was fou...

Texas Killing Fields: Verdict Reached in James Elmore Trial

A Texas jury reached a verdict in James Elmore's manslaughter trial, who was charged in connection with 16-year-old Laura Miller's 1984 death. Elmore admitted t...

Father Tells Man Convicted in Daughter's Cold Case Death 'Thank You'

Laura Miller's parents confronted James Elmore at his sentencing for his role in their daughter's 1984 death. Through tears, Janet Miller told Elmore, "You had ...

Texas Killing Fields Trial | TX v. James Elmore | Full Verdict

A Texas jury reached a verdict in James Elmore's manslaughter trial, who was charged in connection with 16-year-old Laura Miller's 1984 death. A day later, Elmo...

Surgeon Called Missing Lawyer a 'Scumbag,' Attorney Says

Jacob Pillsbury, an attorney who represented a woman sued by Dr. Tomasz Kosowski, took the stand and described his interactions with the surgeon during a civil ...

Strange Noises Heard When Lawyer Mysteriously Vanished

A man who worked in the same building as Steven Cozzi's law firm described hearing strange noises coming from an office bathroom shortly before the Largo attorn...

Surveillance Shows Man Lugging 'Something' After Lawyer Vanishes

Surveillance video from March 21, 2023, was shown in court Monday during the trial of Dr. Tomasz Kosowski, who is accused of killing Largo attorney Steven Cozzi...

Surgeon Bought Truck Said to Match One Seen Before Lawyer Vanished

A man who sold his gray Toyota Tundra to Dr. Tomasz Kosowski in December 2022 testified Tuesday in Kosowski's trial for the alleged killing of Largo attorney St...

Nick Reiner Avoids Death Penalty in Parents' Murder Case

Prosecutors will not seek the death penalty against Nick Reiner, who is accused of fatally stabbing his parents, renowned Hollywood director Rob Reiner and his ...

'Body' Covered in Red Blanket In Back of Surgeon's Truck: Police

On Tuesday, Jerry Hunt, with the Largo Police Department, took the stand in the case against Dr. Tomasz Kosowski. He detailed several surveillance videos from t...

Surgeon Accused of Murder Had Bruises All Over His Body: Deputy

A member of the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office took the stand Wednesday to discuss photos she took of the defendant, Dr. Tomasz Kosowski, after he was arreste...

Accused Killer Surgeon's Bizarre Request Leaves Courtroom STUNNED

In a bizarre moment during his murder trial, self-represented surgeon Dr. Tomasz Kosowski challenged the prosecutor over a trash bag found in his car. The prose...

Surgeon's Truck Holds Chilling Clue After Lawyer Vanished

Several members of the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office took the stand on Wednesday to discuss the tests done on the truck that reportedly belonged to Dr. Tomas...

Plastic Surgeon Caught 'Sucking Fingers' to Destroy Murder Evidence: Cop

Video of plastic surgeon Dr. Tomasz Kosowski in the back of a police cruiser after his arrest was played in court Tuesday. Detective Jerry Hunt testified that K...

How a Plastic Surgeon Became a Murder Suspect: Investigator

Lead investigator Jerry Hunt testified about the investigation into the disappearance of Largo attorney Steven Cozzi, whose body has never been found. Hunt deta...

Masks, Suspicious Items Found Inside Bag Located in Surgeon's Car

While Ashley Luth, with the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office, took the stand, she detailed items that were found inside the vehicle belonging to Dr. Tomasz Koso...

Surgeon Representing Himself Raises Hand During His Own Murder Trial

After the lunch break, Dr. Tomasz Kosowski raised his hand in the courtroom to address the judge, telling her that he objected to having a microphone positioned...

Lawyer Breaks Down Hearing His 911 Call for Missing Colleague

Jake Blanchard, an attorney who oversaw the work of Steven Cozzi at his firm, recalled the disturbing discovery that followed Cozzi's disappearance in March 202...

Attorney's Husband Remembers Their Final Kiss Before He Vanished

Steven Cozzi's husband, Michael Montgomery, took the stand as Dr. Tomasz Kosowski's murder trial continued, describing their marriage and the final morning they...

Attorney's Husband Feared Surgeon Now Accused of Killing Him

Michael Montgomery, Steven Cozzi's husband, took the stand Monday in the trial against Dr. Tomasz Kosowski. Montgomery described his relationship with Cozzi and...

Surgeon Accused of 'Cold and Calculated' Murder of Attorney: State

On Monday, the trial against Dr. Tomasz Kosowski began. He is accused of killing Largo attorney Steven Cozzi, whose body has never been found. The prosecution s...

Prosecutors Reveal Caleb Flynn's Chilling Text to His Mistress

Prosecutors delivered opening statements in Caleb Flynn's murder trial, accusing the former American Idol contestant of killing his wife, Ashley, to continue hi...

American Idol Contestant Admits Affair, Denies Killing His Wife

Caleb Flynn's defense acknowledged that the former American Idol contestant had an affair, but argued that the affair does not make him a killer. During opening...

American Idol Trial: Jurors See Where Ashley Flynn Was Killed

The murder trial of Caleb Flynn began with opening statements and a jury view before witness testimony. The jurors viewed the scene where Caleb allegedly shot a...

Caleb Flynn Bodycam Footage: 'Ashley's Dead, She's Gone'

The court sees bodycam footage of patrol officer Alexandra Giampapa responding to Ashley Flynn's deadly shooting. In the footage, Caleb Flynn, who's visibly dis...

American Idol Murder Trial | OH v. Caleb Flynn | Full Openings

Opening statements in the trial against Caleb Flynn began on Friday, who faces trial for murder and tampering with evidence in the death of his wife, Ashley Fly...

Caleb Flynn Breaks Down Hearing His Own 911 Call in Court

Caleb Flynn broke down in court as jurors heard the frantic 911 call he made after his wife, Ashley Flynn, was fatally shot. Flynn told the dispatcher that some...

Ashley Flynn Found Shot to Death in Her Bed, Officer Testifies

Sgt. Corey Rismiller testified about the moment he entered Ashley Flynn's bedroom after Caleb Flynn reported that his wife had been shot. Rismiller described se...

American Idol Murder Trial: Most Shocking Moments From Openings

During the trial of American Idol star Caleb Flynn, opening statements began Friday as prosecutors and the defense laid out their competing theories in the case...

Jail Inmate Reveals What 'Witch Doctor' Said About Missing Mom, Her Son

A jail inmate testified that Shannon Ryan made disturbing comments about missing mother Leila Cavett and her young son while the two were in a Broward County ja...

'No Forced Entry' Found In Flynn Home After Wife's Murder: Special Agent

On Monday, an Ohio BCI special agent took the stand in the trial against Caleb Flynn, who is accused of killing his wife, Ashley. Caleb reportedly staged the sc...

Caleb Flynn BAWLS as Photos of Dead Wife Shown in Murder Trial

On Monday, Caleb Flynn was back in court for the murder of his wife, Ashley. While an Ohio BCI special agent was on the stand, photos of the crime scene where A...

Caleb Flynn Seems to Mouth 'Oh My God' While Autopsy Photos Shown

Caleb Flynn is currently on trial for the death of his wife. Prosecutors allege Flynn staged the scene to look like a home invasion and initially told police an...

Caleb Flynn's Defense Clashes with Crime Scene Agent

While Caleb Flynn's defense team cross-examined BCI crime scene agent David Hammond, the exchange grew somewhat tense. Hammond addressed potential gaps in the i...

Pastor's Wife Died From Close-Range Gunshots To the Head: Forensic Pathologist

Bryan Casto, who works for the Montgomery County Coroner's Office, took the stand Monday to discuss the autopsy of Ashley Flynn. Her husband, Caleb, is currentl...

Caleb Flynn 'Didn't Make Sense' After Wife's Murder: Sister

Kayla Keyt, Ashley Flynn's sister, testified about what Caleb Flynn told her family after Ashley was shot and killed in February 2026. Keyt recalled Flynn sayin...

Mother of Murdered Pastor's Wife Cries on the Stand

Ashley Flynn's mother took the stand on Tuesday in the case against her husband, Caleb. She talked about her relationship with her daughter and Caleb before her...

Ashley Flynn's Dad Googled: 'Can a Christian Man Snap?'

Todd Smith, the father of Ashley Flynn, took the stand and discussed the day his daughter died in February 2026. He stated that when he got the call about his d...

Caleb Flynn Judge Threatens Sanctions in Murder Trial

The judge in Caleb Flynn's murder trial threatened sanctions after expressing frustration over courtroom decorum as testimony continued in the case. Flynn is ac...

Caleb Flynn's Daughter 'Not Surprised' By His Affair

Ashley Flynn's sister Kayla Keyt testified about how Ashley's two daughters reacted after learning their father, Caleb Flynn, had an affair with a woman he work...

Caleb Flynn's Mistress 'Lost' Phone, Laptop Before Murder

Day three of testimony in Caleb Flynn's murder trial included evidence involving his alleged mistress. CourtTV's Julia Jenae spoke with Law

Pastor's Neighbor Saw No Activity on Cameras During Murder

A neighbor of Caleb and Ashley Flynn testified about what she saw on February 16, 2026, the day Ashley was killed. She said her three dogs never alerted her to ...

Caleb Flynn Jury's Reaction to Emotional Family Testimony

On Tuesday, Angenette Levy, host of Law

Detective Reveals Where Caleb Flynn's Mistress Was During Murder

n Wednesday, Zachary Farkas, with the City of Dayton Police Department, took the stand to discuss interviews he did with the mistress of Caleb Flynn after his w...

Caleb Flynn's Mistress 'Ended Things' Months Before Wife's Murder

On Wednesday, Alleigha Botner took the stand to detail her relationship with Caleb Flynn. She testified about how the relationship began and said she initially ...

VERDICT: 'Killer' Surgeon Tomasz Kosowski Learns His Fate

Judge Joseph Bulone delivered a quick verdict in Tomasz Kosowski's bench trial, where he faced charges of first-degree murder in the 2023 death of attorney Stev...

Caleb Flynn Hated Wife, Said She Cheated On Him: Mistress

Alleigha Botner, Caleb Flynn's alleged mistress, took the stand Wednesday to detail their relationship. She testified during Flynn's murder trial that they were...

Caleb Flynn Wished He Could Kill His Wife, Not Go To Jail: Mistress

Alleigha Botner, Caleb Flynn's alleged mistress, testified that Flynn repeatedly talked about wanting his wife, Ashley, out of his life. She said Flynn made com...

Caleb Flynn Planned to Divorce Wife on Day She Was Killed: Mistress

Caleb Flynn reportedly told his mistress, Alleigha Botner, that he planned to divorce his wife, Ashley, on February 16, 2026. Botner testified that Flynn said h...

Caleb Flynn's Wife Allegedly Knew About Affair

Caleb Flynn's mistress was a major topic of conversation on the witness stand on Wednesday. Several investigators took the stand to talk about their interviews ...

Pastor's Mistress Has No Immunity in Murder Trial, Lawyer Says

Caleb Flynn's mistress, Alleigha Botner, continued her shocking testimony Thursday in his murder trial, reading aloud texts Flynn sent before the murder in whic...

Mistress Reads Pastor's Texts About Hating Wife Before Her Murder

Caleb Flynn's mistress, Alleigha Botner, read text messages they exchanged before his wife, Ashley, was murdered in February 2026. In the messages, Flynn expres...

Caleb Flynn Asked Mistress to 'Hire Someone' to Kill Wife

Alleigha Botner was back on the stand Thursday to read more messages between her and Caleb Flynn during their affair. Some of the messages in June 2025 talked a...

Pastor's Mistress Begged Him to Leave His Wife Over Text

On Thursday, Alleigha Botner read more messages between her and Caleb Flynn in which she begged him to leave his wife. She gave him deadlines to leave his wife,...

Pastor's Mistress Admits She Resented His Wife

During cross-examination in Caleb Flynn's murder trial, Alleigha Botner read more text messages between herself and Flynn from 2025, when they were having an af...

Pastor's Mistress Reveals His First Words After Wife's Murder

At the conclusion of Alleigha Botner's direct examination by the prosecution, she detailed what happened on February 16, 2026, after Ashley Flynn was found dead...

Caleb Flynn's Mistress Believed He Killed His Wife

During cross-examination of Alleigha Botner, the defense asked her about several Google searches she made after Ashley Flynn was murdered in her home in Februar...

Caleb Flynn's Secret Love Songs for Mistress Put on Blast in Court

Two songs tied to Caleb Flynn's relationship with his mistress, Alleigha Botner, were played for the jury Thursday in Flynn's murder trial. An Ohio Bureau of Cr...

Caleb Flynn's Devices Reveal Timeline Before 911 Call

Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation Cyber Crime Unit expert Joseph Wilhelm testified Thursday about the digital evidence recovered from Caleb Flynn's iPhone, ...

Mysterious Hitman Tip Targeting Caleb Flynn's Wife Investigated by FBI

Andrea Kinzig, a special agent with the FBI, discussed tips that were looked into regarding the death of Ashley Flynn. One of those tips claimed that a hitman h...

Ashley Flynn's Phone Showed No Evidence She Had An Affair: FBI

On Friday, a special agent with the FBI took the stand in the case against Caleb Flynn. The agent, Andrea Kinzig, performed an extraction from Ashley Flynn's ph...

Caleb Flynn's Jury Seems 'Skeptical' of His Story

On Friday, Angenette Levy, host of Law

Nurse Who Neglected Medically Fragile Child Sentenced

Sharlene Pflugrad, a former in-home care nurse convicted of neglecting a medically fragile child was sentenced to 30 months in prison followed 30 months of prob...

Pastor's Mistress: Full Cross-Examination | OH v. Caleb Flynn

During her cross-examination, Alleigha Botner read more text message exchanges between her and Caleb Flynn, noting how much she loved him. Botner also acknowled...

Ohio Mom Learns Fate in Horrifying Child Abuse Case

An Ohio judge sentenced Heather Pippen to five years in prison for her role in a child abuse case. Pippen and her boyfriend, Stephanas Golden, were charged with...

Caleb Flynn Was NOT TESTED For Gunshot Residue After Wife's Murder

On Monday, during a third interview with police, it came out that Caleb Flynn was not tested for gunshot residue following his wife's murder. They stated that t...

Both Sides Rest in American Idol Murder Trial

Both the state and the defense have rested thier case in the murder trial against Caleb Flynn. On Monday afternoon, the announcement was made to the jury, and c...

Caleb Flynn's Final Hours Before Wife's Murder Revealed

On Monday, Samantha Reeb, a member of the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation, took the stand to discuss the movements of the Flynn family before Ashley Flynn...

Georgia Locked Up for Decades in Death of Girlfriend's Child

Brandon Robinson was in a Georgia courtroom on Monday to learn his sentence for the 2023 murder of his girlfriend Shelly Perry's six-year-old daughter. A judge ...

'Complete Fabrication:' State Slams Caleb Flynn's Story

On Tuesday, prosecutors delivered their closing argument in Caleb Flynn's murder trial. Flynn, 40, is accused of killing his wife, Ashley, 37, in their Tipp Cit...

Ashley Flynn Paid the 'Ultimate Sacrifice': Prosecution

During the state's rebuttal argument on Tuesday morning, they stated that the case against Caleb Flynn did not go how he thought it would. They claim he wanted ...

Caleb Flynn's Defense Blasts Police Investigation

During closing arguments, Caleb Flynn's defense argued that prosecutors failed to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt. The defense pointed to the lack of...

Lindsay Clancy's Lawyer STUNS Court With Legal Maneuver

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court on Tuesday for a follow-up hearing to her highly publicized mistrial. Kevin Reddington presented an argument stating, "This ent...

'Crybaby' Caleb Flynn GUILTY of Murdering Wife

The jury reached a verdict in the murder case against Caleb Flynn on Tuesday Afternoon, declaring him guilty on all counts. He killed his wife, Ashley, inside t...

Lindsay Clancy Lawyer Drops BOMBSHELL Claim About Her Children

Lindsay Clancy's defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, stunned the courtroom by claiming there is no evidence that Clancy killed her three children. Law

Caleb Flynn BAWLS After Guilty Verdict Read in Court

Former 'American Idol' contestant Caleb Flynn was seen bawling at the defense table after the guilty verdict was read in court Tuesday afternoon. The jury found...

Microsoft Exec Killer Pleads Not Guilty to Sex Crime Charges

Mario Fernandez Saldana, who was convicted of first-degree murder and solicitation to commit a capital felony in the shooting death of Microsoft executive Jared...

Ashley Flynn's Family Cries, Hugs Prosecutors After Guilty Verdict

Ashley Flynn's family was overcome with emotion Tuesday afternoon after Caleb Flynn was convicted in her murder. As they left the courtroom, family members hugg...

Officer Reveals Grisly Details of Miami Triple-Murder Scene

On Wednesday, the lead crime scene investigator in the case against Alberto Sierra detailed what the crime scene looked like when she arrived in November 2012. ...

Man Convicted of Strangling Girlfriend Sentenced to Life

Jason Palmer was sentenced to life in prison, with the possibility of parole after 15 years, for the death of his girlfriend, Rachel Prince. Palmer was convicte...

Florida Woman Pleads Guilty to Killing Missing Roommate

Gisselle Victoria-Gonzalez, who was accused of killing her roommate, Runyleidy Medina-Pacheco, was sentenced to 25 years after pleading guilty to second-degree ...

Mom, 2 Young Daughters Found Dead in Closet: Firefighter

Richard Ramos with the Miami-Dade Fire Rescue took the stand in the case against Alberto Sierra. Ramos was one of the first responders to a Florida home in Nove...

Accused Uncle Cries As Nurse Describes Five-Year-Old's Injuries

Krystal Beck, a registered nurse who cared for five-year-old Paitin Fields when she was brought into the ER, took the stand. She discussed the injuries that she...

Five-Year-Old Abused, Murdered by Her Teen Uncle: State

Opening statements began Thursday in the trial of David Prevatte, who is accused of killing and sexually abusing his 5-year-old niece, Paitin Fields, in 2017. P...

Uncle Denies Assaulting, Killing 5-Year-Old Niece: Defense

The defense gave its opening statement in the case against David Prevatte, stating that he did not "sexually assault or murder" his 5-year-old niece, Paitin Fie...

Five-Year-Old Appeared to Have Been Strangled: Doctor

Doctor Brian McGrath testified that he noticed a distinct line of petechiae on 5-year-old Paitin Fields' neck. He said the marks were consistent with strangulat...

Five-Year-Old Was Unresponsive, Fighting to Live: Doctor

Doctor Brian McGrath recalled the terrifying moment 5-year-old Paitin Fields arrived at the ER in the early morning hours of Nov. 13, 2017. He testified that Pa...

Caleb Flynn Cries In Court Days After Jury Finds Him Guilty

Caleb Flynn appeared in court Thursday afternoon for the first time since a jury found him guilty earlier this week. During the hearing, the judge went over the...

Grandma's Heartbreaking 911 Call After 5-Year-Old Collapses

Friday morning, the courtroom listened to the 911 call made by Lisa Hunt, the mother of David Prevatte, on November 13, 2017. Hunt was visibly in tears as the c...

Killer's DNA Found Under Fingernails of all Three Murder Victims: Detective

On Thursday, the detective investigating the deaths of Gladys Machado and her two young daughters, Julia and Daniela Padron, stated that the DNA of Alberto Sier...

Husband of Victim Never Called Police After Triple Murders: Detective

A detective who was looking into the deaths of Gladys Machado and her two young daughters, Julia and Daniela Padron, who were ages 6 and 3 at the time of the mu...

Grandmother Breaks Down Recalling 5-Year-Old's Death

Lisa Hunt, the mother of David Prevatte, took the stand Friday and detailed when she saw her five-year-old granddaughter Paitin Fields, "seizing on the couch." ...

Killer Showed No Emotion Discussing Triple Murder: Detective

Lead detective Juan Carlos Chaidez testified about an interview with Alberto Sierra, who pleaded guilty to killing his estranged wife, Gladys Machado, and her t...

Grandma: Accused Killer Tried to Save Unconscious Niece

While Lisa Hunt, the mother of David Prevatte, was on the stand, she discussed finding her five-year-old niece unconscious on her living room couch. After she f...

Accused Niece Killer Blows Kiss to The Courtroom Gallery

After David Prevatte's mother finished testifying Friday, he appeared to blow a kiss to someone in the courtroom gallery. Prevatte is currently on trial for the...

Betrayal in the Bloodline Murder Trial | NC v. David Prevatte | Full Openings

Opening statements in the case against David Prevatte began Thursday morning. He is accused of strangling and abusing his five-year-old niece in November 2017. ...

Vegas 'Bride' Sentenced for Gambling-Fueled Marriage Fraud

Jiaying Chen, who pleaded guilty to marrying multiple men for gambling money, was sentenced on Tuesday. The Las Vegas woman, who submitted 15 marriage applicati...

Defense Questions Whether DNA Was Left in UNC Murder

On Wednesday, the defense gave its opening statement in the case against Miguel Salguero-Olivares. He is accused of assaulting and killing 19-year-old Faith Hed...

Autopsy Reveals Strangulation Marks on 5-Year-Old: Expert

The forensic pathologist who did the autopsy for five-year-old Paitin Feilds took the stand to discuss her injuries. She noted that the child "appeared healthy"...

Crucial Evidence Was Discarded After 5-Year-Old's Death: Investigator

On Tuesday, Daniel L. Wells, a lieutenant with the Crime Scene Investigation, was back on the stand in the case against David Prevatte. He is accused of abusing...

5-Year-Old's Family Discussed Ulterior Motives in Her Murder: Detective

A detective from the Pender County Sheriff's Office took the stand on Tuesday to discuss his investigation into David Prevatte. Prevatte was identified as a sus...

Best Friend Cries Recalling Finding Faith Hedgepeth Dead

While Karena Rosario, who was living with Faith Hedgepath at the time of her murder and was best friends, was on the stand, she detailed what happened before Fa...

Accused Uncle's Boxers Could Hold Key to Child's Murder

As trial continues, a forensic biologist testified that testing on David Prevatte's boxer shorts revealed three areas with indications of blood. She took cuttin...

Tomasz Kosowski Yells at Prosecutor: 'Shut Up!'

During Thursday's hearing, convicted killer Tomasz Kosowski presented two motions on his own before sentencing. One asked for the return of personal property se...

Friend Saw Murdered UNC Student's Roommate With Blood

Jordan McCrary, a friend of Karina, Faith Hedgepeth's roommate, took the stand to discuss the events of the night of September 7, 2012. He recalled seeing both ...

911 Call: Faith Hedgepeth's Roommate Begs for Help

The 911 dispatcher who was working the morning of September 7, 2012, took the stand Thursday to play the 911 call made by Faith Hedgepeth's roommate. Her roomma...

Friend Tears Up Recalling Finding Murdered UNC Student

Marisol Rangel, who was friends with Faith Hedgepeth, took the stand and discussed finding her dead inside her apartment in September 2012. She remembered walki...

Miguel Salguero-Olivares Tears Up at Crime Scene Video

While crime scene video from inside the apartment where Faith Hedgepeth was played in court, Miguel Salguero-Olivares appeared teary-eyed and at times shook his...

DNA Findings Raise New Questions in 5-Year-Old's Murder

New DNA testing identified David Prevatte and 5-year-old Paitin Fields as possible contributors to a DNA mixture found on red earbuds collected as evidence, a D...

Accused UNC Student Killer Looks Away at Gruesome Photos

The crime scene investigator was back on the stand Friday in the case against Miguel Salguero-Olivares. He is accused of abusing and killing 19-year-old UNC Cha...

Faith Hedgepeth's Horrific Cause of Death Revealed

Dr. Lauren Scott, the associate chief medical examiner who did an autopsy on Faith Hedgepeth, took the stand to discuss her injuries. Dr. Scott noted that Hedge...

DNA BOMBSHELL in Uncle's Trial for 5-Year-Old's Murder

A forensic DNA expert testified in the murder trial of David Prevatte, who is accused of killing his 5-year-old niece, Paitin Fields. The expert said testing fo...

The Faith Hedgepeth Murder Trial | NC v. Miguel Salguero-Olivares | Full Opening

Both the state and defense gave their opening statements against Miguel Salguero-Olivares, who is accused of assaulting and killing 19-year-old Faith Hedgepeth ...

7-Year-Old Was Forced to Carry Logs in the Snow: Stepson

Damian Hauschultz, the stepson of Timothy Hauschultz, took the stand to discuss what happened on April 20, 2018. This was the day that 7-year-old Ethan Hauschul...

Horse Farm Owner GRILLED on 'Self-Defense' Shooting Claim

Caylen Deller, who is accused of killing her ex-boyfriend, Chad Mullen, dumping his body in a pond and using a horse to drag it to a shallow grave, faced tough ...

Horse Stables Owner Says Ex Charged at Her With Hammer

Caylen Deller, who's accused of killing her ex-boyfriend, Chad Mullen, took the stand in her own defense. Deller, who believed Mullen sexually assaulted her dau...

Stables Owner Allegedly Used Her Horse to Drag Ex's Body

Caylen Deller's former boyfriend, Kenneth Waddell, took the stand on Tuesday and claimed that Deller confessed to luring her ex-boyfriend, Chad Mullen, and shoo...

7-Year-Old Was Cold, Unresponsive and Turning Blue: Doctor

Several medical staff who treated 7-year-old Ethan Hauschultz testified Tuesday about his condition when he arrived at the ER in April 2018. Critical care param...

Deputy Sheds Tears Recalling Seeing 7-Year-Old in ER

A Manitowoc County sheriff's deputy became emotional while testifying at the trial of Timothy Hauschultz, who is accused of killing 7-year-old Ethan Hauschultz....

'Tragic' Death of 7-Year-Old Blamed on Teen Son: Defense

The defense delivered its opening statement Tuesday in the trial of Timothy Hauschultz, who is accused of killing his 7-year-old great-nephew, Ethan Hauschultz,...

Judge Drops Rape Charge Against Accused Killer Uncle

A judge dismissed the statutory rape charge against David Prevatte in the case involving the death and alleged assault of 5-year-old Paitin Fields, ruling that ...

Accused Uncle's Defense Moves to Toss Charges in 5-Year-Old's Murder Case

After the state rested its case in the murder and assault trial involving 5-year-old Paitin Fields, the defense moved to dismiss the charges, arguing prosecutor...

Investigator Details Unknown DNA in UNC Student's Murder

Johnnie Britt, the lead investigator for the murder case of Faith Hedgepeth, took the stand Monday. She detailed the investigation and noted that some of the sw...

MISTRIAL Declared in David Prevatte Trial

A judge declared a mistrial in David Prevatte's murder trial Thursday after jury misconduct raised concerns about whether he could receive a fair trial. Several...

Judge Calls Out Murdaugh Lawyers Amid Heated Evidence Dispute

The judge overseeing Alex Murdaugh's upcoming retrial admonished attorneys on both sides during a dispute over crime-scene evidence, telling them to stop the ba...

7-Year-Old Forced to Carry Logs Died of Hypothermia: Expert

Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Wieslawa Tlomak testified Friday about the autopsy of 7-year-old Ethan Hauschultz, who died in April 2018. She said Ethan had multipl...

Former Cheerleader Laken Snelling Sentenced for Infant's Death

Laken Snelling, the former University of Kentucky student-athlete, who pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter, was sentenced on Friday. Snelling, 22, was g...

Alex Murdaugh Appears in Court Ahead of Murder Retrial

Alex Murdaugh walked into court today for a pretrial hearing ahead of his upcoming retrial in the murders of his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul. The hearing has fo...

Judge Probes Juror's Secret KKK Knowledge in 5-Year-Old's Murder

Drama emerged in the trial against David Prevatte on Thursday as the judge investigated potential juror misconduct involving a fellow juror's alleged undisclose...

'Bachelor' Scammer Gets SHOCKING Sentence in Pregnancy Case

On Friday, Laura Owens was sentenced to months of probation after pleading guilty to felony charges stemming from false pregnancy claims involving "Bachelor" st...

Business Partner's $100K Grudge Behind Double Murder: State

Opening statements began Monday in Andrew Griffin's double-murder trial, where he is accused of killing his former business partner, Thomas Strussion, and Strus...

Mamta Bhatt Case: Husband's Saw Purchase Caught on Camera

A Home Depot corporate investigator testified about sales records and surveillance footage documenting the purchase of a Ryobi reciprocating saw, battery starte...

Blue Glow on Trash Can Raises Questions in Mamta Bhatt Case

A crime scene investigator testified in the Naresh Bhatt trial that Blue Star testing produced a blue glow on multiple areas of a trash can at the home he share...

Naresh Bhatt Saw: Investigator Reveals DISTURBING Findings

A forensic investigator testified about suspected bloodstains and hair-like strands found inside a saw collected during the investigation into the disappearance...

Business Partner Called Double Murder a 'Mob Hit': Victim's Dad

Eddie Cutrer, Angela Strussion's father, took the stand in Andrew Griffin's double-murder trial. Cutrer detailed hearing the horrific news of his daughter's pas...

Business Gone Bad Murder Trial: Firefighter Details Finding Bodies

Fire captain Jeremy Rife Jr. detailed arriving at the crime scene and immediately experiencing heavy smoke and low visibility upon entering the home. Captain Ri...

Naresh Bhatt's Deleted Facebook Post Alarmed Friends

A friend of Naresh Bhatt testified about a sarcastic Facebook post he saw before Mamta Bhatt disappeared, prompting him and another friend to confront Naresh ab...

Naresh Bhatt Trial Witness Upset After Judge's Warning

A witness appeared frustrated Monday afternoon after the judge ordered him to stay off social media until the trial against Naresh Bhatt concludes, as attorneys...

Naresh Bhatt's Shocking Search History About Remarriage

A witness testified about Google searches attributed to Naresh Bhatt's military account, including queries about what happens when a spouse dies and how long it...

Double Murder Scene Photos Reveal 3 Fire Starting Points

A fire investigator identified three starting points for the fire inside the Strussion home, where Thomas and Angeka Strussion were found dead in September 2021...

Deadly Discipline Trial | WI v. Timothy Hauschultz | Full Openings

Opening statements in the case against Timothy Hauschultz happened earlier this week. He is accused of being part of his 7-year-old great-nephew Ethan's death i...

Naresh Bhatt's Neighbor Recalls Talk of Divorce

A neighbor of Naresh Bhatt testified that Bhatt previously told him his marriage to Mamta was "not working" and that he was unhappy. The witness said Bhatt also...

Naresh Bhatt Pursued New Love Before Wife Vanished: Messages

Messages presented in court show Naresh Bhatt asking a contact to introduce him to a Colombian woman, saying he wanted to fall in love and eventually marry her....

Naresh Bhatt, Mamta's Messages Reveal Bitter Marriage Dispute

Texts exchanged between Naresh Bhatt and Mamta in February 2024 reveal escalating marital tensions months before Mamta's disappearance. The messages show the co...

Restaurant Investor Said He 'Killed Two People': Witness

A longtime family friend of Andrew Griffin testified that he overheard Griffin say, "I had to go get my money and I killed two people," during a phone call. Gri...

Boyfriend Said Teen Fell From Truck Before Her Death: Mom

Lynne Ringquist, the mother of 17-year-old Sophie, took the stand as the first witness in the case against Cooper Ouellette. He is accused of her death in May 2...

Police Found Mamta Bhatt Upset Months Before She Vanished

A Manassas Park police officer testified that he responded to a domestic call at Naresh and Mamta Bhatt's home on Feb. 14, 2024, months before Mamta disappeared...

Accused Killer BAWLS as Police Tell Him Girlfriend Died

On Friday, a police interview with Cooper Ouellette was played in court. Ouellette told detectives he was driving with his girlfriend, 17-year-old Sophie Ringqu...

Teen's Deadly Injuries Don't Match Boyfriend's Story: Doctor

On Friday, Dr. Gregory Vincent, an associate medical examiner, testified in the trial against Cooper Ouellette. He is accused in the death of his 17-year-old gi...

OH v. Andrew Griffin | Business Gone Bad Murder Trial | Full Openings

Opening statements began Monday in Andrew Griffin's trial, who is accused of killing his business partner, Thomas Strussion, and his wife, Angela Strussion. Pro...

Naresh Bhatt's SHOCKING Search About 'Donating' His Baby

An Investigator testified about Google searches found on Naresh Bhatt's phone, including a search asking, "Can I donate my baby to my friend?" on Aug. 17, 2024,...

Drunk Teen's COLD Reaction After Killing Jogger: Bodycam

Bodycam footage shown at Addison Bowell's sentencing hearing was shown to the court. In the video, a police officer who was questioning the teen at her home ask...

Alleged Cheating, Abusive Texts Shed Light on Bhatt Marriage

Text messages presented in Naresh Bhatt's trial are shedding light on alleged infidelity and marital problems before his wife, Mamta Bhatt, disappeared in July ...

Judge Demands Answers as Oregon Girlfriend Murder Trial Nears

A judge grew visibly frustrated with prosecutors during a pretrial hearing in the murder case of an Oregon man accused of killing his girlfriend, Mariah King. K...

Lindsay Clancy Attends Hearing Over Possible Retrial in Kids' Deaths

Monday morning, Lindsay Clancy was back in a Massachusetts courtroom for a hearing that could determine whether she will face a second trial in the deaths of he...

Lindsay Clancy Back In Court After Mistrial

Lindsay Clancy is back in a Plymouth courtroom Monday following a mistrial in her murder trial, when jurors were unable to reach a unanimous verdict in the kill...

Lindsay Clancy Lawyer SNAPS: 'You're Not Going to Stop Me!'

Things got heated during a hearing over whether Lindsay Clancy will face a second trial in the deaths of her three children. Clancy's attorney, Kevin Reddington...

Lindsay Clancy Retrial Plans Still Up in the Air

Prosecutors told a judge Monday that a retrial is being considered for Lindsay Clancy after her first trial ended in a mistrial in September 2026. However, they...

Accused Girlfriend Killer's Call Home Left Mom Stunned

Kerri Ouellette testified Monday in the murder trial of her son, Cooper, who is accused of killing his 17-year-old girlfriend, Sophie, in May 2023. She recalled...

Lindsay Clancy Hearing Takes TENSE Turn With Judge

Lindsay Clancy returned to a Plymouth courtroom Monday for a hearing following the mistrial in her murder case. Her defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, and Judg...

Mamta Bhatt's Brother Testifies They Tried to Stop Her Wedding

Mamta Bhatt's brother took the stand and testified about concerns surrounding her marriage to Naresh Bhatt, including revealing they had warned Mamta not to mar...